Egalitarianism vs. Education

New York Sun columnist Andrew Wolf on how to use schools to destroy cities:

The test for the city's "science" schools, Stuyvesant, Bronx Science, and Brooklyn Tech, has become the ultimate high-stakes test. The reason is simple. These schools are among the best anywhere, but the choices beyond are abysmal, particularly the schools that children can attend as a matter of right without a special admission process. In Riverdale and dozens of other similar communities in the city, it has long been the widely held belief that if you don't "make" Science or Stuyvesant, you're in deep trouble....

This was recognized by the New York Times, which reported in early 1997 that Kennedy's principal told another prospective Riverdale parent that in order to ensure the safety of her son, she should "teach him to strut, not walk, and to watch what was going on behind him." ...What was left to this parent was the city's Education Option, known as "Ed-Opt" high schools....Places are assigned according to a curve: 16% of the places are reserved for the highest-scoring students, 68% for those in the vast middle, and 16% for those at the bottom....

New York magazine examined this issue more than five years ago, using the Baruch College School as an example of how the system worked. For the 100 openings, 553 students applied from the top scoring group, vying for just 16 places; 878 came from the mid-range group, from which 68 were chosen, and just 63 of the applicants came from bottom, vying for 16 places. Thus, the odds that a low-scoring child would be admitted exceeded 1-in-4; 1-in-13 for the child in the middle, and 1-in-35 for the best performing students. This is meritocracy turned on its head. Of course, this system was created with the best of intentions, not to "leave any child behind." The presumption was that the middle class would fend for itself. And they did, more often than not with their feet. [New York Sun, 11/7/03]

Crackdown on Russian Billionaires for Oppressing Rabbits

The crackdown reached the near-absurd yesterday when [Russian oil company] Yukos faced possible fresh charges for allegedly failing in its duty properly to monitor rabbit coupling at a farm in Siberia. Regional agriculture ministry inspectors found that female and male rabbits were often kept together in groups of up to four, a violation of the norms. "Couplings take place unsystematically, and no zoological-technological records are kept," the Interfax news agency quoted a ministry report as saying. [Daily Telegraph, 11/7/03]

A Victory Against Political Correctness: Rebel Yell Apologizes to Alexander Marriott

From the Las Vegas Review-Journal, October 24, 2003:

UNLV students had a tough time grabbing a copy of the Rebel Yell before class Thursday morning. About 30 distribution stands for the campus newspaper were wiped out of the latest edition. The copies were tossed into several garbage bags and left in the University of Nevada, Las Vegas amphitheater, covered with a sheet that read, "Rebel Yell Wake Up." ...Student columnist Alexander Marriott is not surprised. ...He has been compared to Adolf Hitler and accused of supporting "genocide, rape and slavery." ...The comments came in response to Marriott's opinion piece, "Christopher Columbus, we salute you."... ["COLUMN BACKLASH: Outrage aimed at UNLV paper"]

From the Las Vegas Review-Journal, October 23, 2003:

[Alexander Marriott] was fired Monday following allegations he plagiarized his Sept. 29 column...Judkins said Marriott's column, "Christopher Columbus, we salute you," mirrors a 2002 Capitalism Magazine article, "Did Christopher Columbus Discover America?" written by Michael Berliner...

...Berliner said when he read Marriott's column in the Review-Journal, re-printed in the Oct. 12 opinion pages, he had no problem with the content. "It never struck me that it was plagiarism," he said. Berliner said no one from the Rebel Yell staff ever contacted him before or after firing Marriott. A former professor for 15 years at California State University, Northridge, he said he has graded enough essays to spot plagiarism. Berliner said he and Marriott seem to have similar beliefs, but different writing styles...Berliner said he sent an e-mail to Rebel Yell opinion editor Irene Marquette suggesting Marriott was fired for something other than plagiarism.

...Judkins said she reached her decision to fire Marriott after showing the printed version of the column to two UNLV professors, who compared it to Berliner's article. One was Cathy Scott, a part-time journalism instructor at UNLV. Judkins said she could not recall the name of the other professor who believed Marriott plagiarized. Scott, who has no official connection to the Rebel Yell, said several sentences seemed to be taken directly from Berliner, and the overall writing seemed too advanced for a college student... ["UNLV Rebel Yell columnist accused of plagiarism, fired"]

(This unnamed professor could be "English prof Jane Hafen" according to Las Vegas Review-Journal editorialist Thomas Mitchell, who was told that Hafen was an "instigator of the plagiarism charge.")

Here are some letters defending Alex.

From the Rebel Yell, November 5th, 2003:

A column by Rebel Yell columnist Alexander Marriott on Sept. 29 entitled "Christopher Colombus, We Salute You" was not plagiarized. Mr. Marriott has been reinstated to his position as staff columnist on the Rebel Yell. We apologize to Mr. Marriott for all inaccurate characterizations of his writing.

From the Las Vegas Review-Journal, November 06, 2003:

UNLV's student newspaper has apologized to newly reinstated columnist Alexander Marriott for its allegation that he committed plagiarism. The retraction, apology and notice of Marriott's reinstatement to the Rebel Yell was printed Wednesday. "We apologize to Mr. Marriott for all inaccurate characterizations of his writing," the statement reads...Berliner, an editor at the Ayn Rand Institute in California and a former professor, did not believe his work was appropriated by Marriott. Neither did Gary Peck, executive director of the ACLU of Nevada. The student newspaper's faculty adviser, Mary Hausch, also questioned the allegation. Judkins resigned last week. ["UNLV writer accepts apology from Rebel Yell"]

Writes Megan Lee in the Rebel Yell:

The overall attitude that I have found on this campus consists of a few basic principles. Mostly it is multiculturalism to a ridiculous extent, a very biased denial of the validity or importance of any invention, discovery or idea founded by someone who was not a female or a minority, and the quick silencing of anyone who thinks differently. These attitudes are not conducive to a freethinking university and in my opinion are contradictory to themselves. How can it be that all thoughts are considered to have merit, except for those that differ from a vastly, dare I say, left wing prejudice? We are so concerned about what is politically correct that we do not care what is correct or fair any longer...What kind of a society have we become if in the middle of a university-the place where all things are supposed to be questioned and all thought is supposed to be free-all opposing opinions or conservative voices can be silenced simply because they do not agree with the status quo?

...It's time that the student body understood that stifling the ideas of others makes them no better than their opinion of the man that Mr. Marriott originally thanked. And so, Alexander Marriott, though I have never met you, I salute you for bringing to the surface a problem that has been plaguing our university. I only hope that others who have been bullied, shouted and threatened to silence will once again be able to find their voice and bring back the diversity that makes us a forum for free thought.

Alexander Marriott also writes for Capitalism Magazine.

Related Articles:

Christopher Columbus, We Salute You by Alexander Marriott
The legacy of Columbus was not death and destruction.

Did Christopher Columbus "Discover" America? by Michael Berliner
It was Columbus' discovery for Western Europe that led to the influx of ideas and people on which America was founded--and on which it still rests.

The Real Museum Looters by Keith Lockitch
Iraqi Museum Looting Pales in Comparison to Broad-Daylight Attacks on Western Civilization by Multiculturalists

The Absurdities Underlying Multiculturalism by Walter Williams
For the multiculturist/diversity crowd, culture, ideas, customs, arts and skills are a matter of racial membership where one has no more control over his culture than his race. That's a racist idea but it's politically correct racism. It says that one's convictions, character and values are not determined by personal judgement and choices but genetically determined. In other words, as yesteryear's racists held: race determines identity.

Quackmire

From Cox and Forkum:

This cartoon was inspired by Charles Johnson's LGF post, Press In Quagmire Frenzy:

Well, this was entirely predictable; taking a run around the major media sites this morning reveals the press in full bore Quagmire Mode after yesterday's missile attack that brought down a US helicopter and killed 16 soldiers.

The New York Times: News Analysis: As Casualties in Iraq Mount, Will Resolve Falter?

The Washington Post: New Attacks Intensify Pressure on Bush.

And of course, what would a quagmire be without the Spectre of Vietnam?

Nowhere in any of these reports is the slightest hint of awareness that if the US were to pull out of Iraq now, jihadis around the world would be emboldened to launch more attacks against US interests everywhere, seeing the US as a paper tiger. Osama bin Laden said this outright -- that our withdrawal from Somalia (where there was much less at stake) proved to him the US had no spine.

The media is on the side of the enemy. Their desire to see the US fail in Iraq is palpable. And the Democrats aren't far behind, as their primary concern (after mouthing empty sympathies) is, very obviously, how to use this attack against President Bush.

The war isn't only taking place in the Middle East -- it's right here in America too.

How the National Park Service Treats Alaskans

The Pacific Legal Foundation, a prominent constitutional public interest law firm, has sued the Federal government over its denial of a family's only access road to its property trapped inside the Wrangell-St. Elias Park in Alaska. The National Park Service has been bullying this family for most of the year, refusing to allow it access over an existing right of way. The Bush Administration has so far refused to intervene and reign in the agency. This case is typical of National Park Service behavior and should be a clear warning against this agency's presence anywhere. The National Park Service not only exemplifies government mismanagement of its own land, its authority and exercise of power supersedes the moral right of private property.

One reason why this case is very important to the viros is that they are trying to redefine guaranteed rights of way to private property to exclude "motorized vehicles". Another is that they are trying to establish that a 'right of way' across Federal land is subject to 'environmental review' and therefore denial.--Erich Veyhl

Federal Judge Temporarily Blocks Partial-Birth Abortion Ban in Nebraska

From LifeNews.com:

Shortly after President Bush signed the partial-birth abortion ban into law, a federal judge in [Lincoln,] Nebraska said the pro-life law is unconstitutional and issued a temporary injunction against it. "It seems to me the law is highly suspect, if not a per se violation of the constitution," said U.S. District Judge Richard Kopf. Kopf agreed with a previous Supreme Court decision and said the law should have included a health exception.

[Anti-abortion] groups say a health exception is unnecessary and would make the ban useless as any reason can be given to justify a partial-birth abortion as necessary to protect a mother's health. "While it is also true that Congress found that a health exception is not needed, it is, at the very least, problematic whether I should defer to such a conclusion when the Supreme Court has found otherwise," Kopf said.

[...] U.S. Justice Department attorney Anthony Coppolino told Kopf that he should show deference to Congress' findings that the abortion procedure is not medically necessary. [...]

Kopf also said the bill did not present "an objective" presentation of the facts and had a "serious vagueness problem." He also wondered why Congress didn't invite those who perform partial-birth abortions to testify [to Congress]. [LeRoy Carhart, who performs partial-birth abortions in Omaha] has been in court before in an attempt to block a ban on partial-birth abortions. He sued to overturn Nebraska's state ban and, in 2000, the Supreme Court agreed that the law was unconstitutional. [It] was Kopf who originally ruled that the Nebraska ban was unconstitutional.

Recommended website: www.AbortionisProLife.com

Free Speech is a Right–Unless You Speak Up in Support of America

From the NY Post:

NEW YORK — A 14-year-old New Jersey schoolboy [Scott Switzer, of Colts Neck] — whose dad [a Navy engineer aboard the USS Detroit in the Persian Gulf] and stepdad are in the military — was suspended for five days because he drew a "patriotic" stick figure of a U.S Marine blowing away a Taliban fighter, officials said yesterday. "He's been punished for the drawing," said Tinton Falls [Middle] school superintendent Leonard Kelpsh. "We felt it was highly inappropriate, and we took it very seriously."

...Scott, who turned 14 Tuesday and was headed back to school Wednesday, said he was unjustly disciplined for his sketch of "a war scene." "Truth be told, it's a Marine shooting a terrorist Taliban," he told The Post. "It's just a picture. What upsets me most is that the principal would dare say it's not normal. To me, it's patriotic."

...a local psychologist who examined the teenager said the sketch was benign...Scott's mother said school officials described the drawing as "not the work of a normal mind." Scott said he understood the school's concern for student safety, but was offended by the principal's comments. "Truth be told, I'm more upset that he'd insinuate that I'm mentally unstable," he said. "I'm the class clown. I'm not a bully." ["'Patriotic' Stick Figure Drawing Troubles School", October 29, 2003]

No Scott you are the class hero. The bullies are the monsters who run your school. Compare this action to the professor in the U.S. who advocated the death of American soldiers:

At an anti-war "teach-in" this week, a Columbia University professor called for the defeat of American forces in Iraq and said he would like to see "a million Mogadishus" -- a reference to the Somali city where American soldiers were ambushed, with 18 killed, in 1993. "The only true heroes are those who find ways that help defeat the U.S. military," Nicholas De Genova, assistant professor of anthropology at Columbia University told the audience at Low Library Wednesday night. "I personally would like to see a million Mogadishus." The crowd was largely silent at the remark. They loudly applauded De Genova later when he said, "If we really believe that this war is criminal ... then we have to believe in the victory of the Iraqi people and the defeat of the U.S. war machine." ... [Teach-in organizer Eric] Foner said that because of the university's tradition of freedom of speech, it was unlikely De Genova would suffer professionally in any way because of what he said. "A person's politics have no impact on their employment status here, whether they are promoted, whether they are fired or whether they get tenure," Foner said. [Newsday, 3/27/03]

Related: Academic "Freedom" at Columbia U. and Columbia's Anti-American Professors and Freedom of Speech.

US Raises Spectre of Conscription

From BBC:

[...] The American defence department has begun a recruitment drive for local draft boards, raising questions about a possible revival of conscription. A notice on a department website invites United States citizens over the age of 18 to volunteer for the boards. The board members will decide who can be exempted if a draft is needed. [...] There has been no draft in the US since it was ended by Congress in 1973, the year that US troops pulled out of Vietnam. [...] Pentagon officials have denied any move to re-instate the draft, saying that this would require a conflict of the magnitude of World War II. They say the Selective Service System (SSS), which runs the draft boards, is merely launching a routine recruitment drive as 80% of places are now vacant.

UN Scrambles to Defend Communist Dictator

From BBC: "UN Votes Against US Cuba Embargo":

The embargo has been in place for more than 40 years The United Nations General Assembly has voted overwhelmingly for an end to the United States' 40-year-old economic embargo against Cuba. The vote marks the 12th consecutive year that the assembly has called for an end to the blockade. Only three nations voted against the motion - the US, Israel and the Marshall Islands. Two others abstained. [...] "The blockade is a cruel and absurd policy that finds no support within or outside the United States," Cuban Foreign Minister Perez Roque said.

Clearly Israel--someone who the dictatorship loaded UN consistently votes against--is not outside the United States.

"The crime being committed against Cuba today could very well be committed against any other country tomorrow."

And what crime is that? Failing to sanction and financially support a thug and murderer? What about the crime of Castro enslaving Cubans under communism? Observe the hypocrisy here:

 "Cuba's foreign minister cried victory Friday after the U.N. Human Rights Commission voted against condemning his country's recent crackdown on dissidents....The top United Nation rights watchdog rejected a proposed resolution criticizing Cuba's recent moves against opponents, instead approving a milder resolution Thursday calling for a U.N. rights monitor to visit the island. "The unquestionable majority vote is a clear signal from the Human Rights Commission that Cuba has the right to apply its own laws," [Cuban Foreign Minister] Perez Roque told a news conference. "We express our profound satisfaction." Earlier this month, Cuban tribunals sentenced 75 dissidents to prison terms ranging from 6 to 28 years on charges they were mercenaries working with the American government to harm the island's socialist system...Perez Roque said his country would not comply with the milder resolution, which urged Cuba to accept a visit by U.N. human rights investigator, French jurist Christine Chanet. [AP, April 2003]

Remember who is in charge of the so-called UN "Human Rights" Commission: Libyan leader Colonel Gadaffi. The U.N. Inhuman Joke Commission would be more apropos.

Quoting from "Isn't the U.S. embargo of Cuba the cause of Cuba's economic woes?":

As wealthy as Americans are, is the United States the only country in the world that has wealth? The fact is all the countries in Europe, South America, Asia, etc. have trade relations with Cuba. So the real question is: why isn't Cuba rich from its trade with all these other countries?

The reason why Cuba is so poor is that the right to life -- the moral-political basis of a free market -- and all the corollaries of that right (liberty, property, speech, etc.) do not legally exist in Cuba. In Cuba there is no private property, no private employers (the only employer is the state), and the only honest way to support oneself in Cuba is in the 'black market.'

Perhaps, the real reason that American Leftists want the U.S. to establish normal relations with Cuba is that once we do so, they can further bleed Americans taxpayers dry to support the Castro regime, as they do to support other bankrupt, socialist regimes in other countries.

To send money to Cuba will only further enrich Castro, as all foreign funds invested there do now (since foreign investors don't pay Cubans, but pay the Castro regime, from which the actual workers only receive a miniscule portion). It is the looters in these foreign countries, ready to "profit" from slave labor, that prop up and empower the Castro regime. It is they along with Dictator Fidel Castro who should be condemned. 

It is Cuba's absolute socialist system--the hallmark of totalitarianism--that should be condemned--not the U.S. embargo.

Recommend reading:

Recommended websites: LibertyForCuba.com and UNisEvil.com.

Lessons from Britain’s Campaign Against the Slave Trade

Amity Shlaes writes an interesting column on Britain's campaign against the slave trade in the 19th century, and the lessons for the present:

"A mighty empire launches an unprecedented military campaign. It will patrol the globe to end a heinous and uncivilized form of behavior. Financing this pre-emptive project demands great sacrifices. Old allies refuse to participate. The empire's lonely unilateral exercise drags on for decades, costing thousands of lives. Observers from Cuba to Moscow assume that this folly will bring down the empire." [New York Sun, 11/4/03]

Poking Fun at Democratic ‘Multilateralism’

Mark Steyn, again:

[S]o eager is Kerry to subordinate U.S. foreign policy to Saddam's patrons that his attacks on America's real allies have become increasingly obnoxious. In the last presidential debate, Kerry said:

''This president has done it wrong every step of the way. He promised that he would have a real coalition. He has a fraudulent coalition.''

... It's taken as a given among Democrats that somehow this administration has needlessly offended the French and Germans. But insulting Britain, Australia and Poland as a cheap way to get at Bush demonstrates your superior sense of the subtleties of foreign policy? I'd say it's going to be very difficult for President Kerry to work with these chaps after his election victory--or I would say it if I could type that sentence without collapsing in giggles.

The really ''fraudulent'' coalition is the one Kerry wants: one that gives the Belgians and Syrians a veto over U.S. action for nothing in return. The ''fraudulent'' coalition is Clark's from the Kosovo war, where all ''allies'' were entitled to advance operational information regardless of whether they were actually contributing to any of the operations, and where, as Clark himself noted in his memoir, ''one of the French officers working at NATO headquarters had given key portions of the operations plans to the Serbs.'' [Mark Steyn, Chicago Sun-Times, 11/2/03]

Oppressive Taxes and Respect for Law

More Signs That Taxes Are Oppressive:

The number of Americans who believe it's OK to cheat "a little here and there" on their taxes has risen 50 percent in the past four years, a government survey says -- a trend that new IRS Commissioner Mark Everson promises to reverse by going after scofflaws at all income levels.... The percentage of people who agreed with the statement that it was every American's civic duty to pay his fair share of taxes decreased from 81 percent in 1999 to 68 percent in 2003. [Yahoo News]

“Because Saddam is gone, now I’m getting married!”

From the Washington Post:

Freed of an onerous Baath Party bureaucracy that sought to regulate even the most fundamental aspects of Iraqi life -- such as who married whom -- Iraqis lately are tying the knot in numbers not seen in recent memory. Before President Saddam Hussein was toppled, the ruling party imposed a complex and strict set of matrimonial rules on Iraqis, particularly on members of the military.... "Because Saddam is gone, now I'm getting married!" said Wasim Adel, 27, beaming beside his bride, Sheelan Shafeeq, 18, in a crowded corridor at Karrada city hall, which serves a neighborhood in central Baghdad. The hallway was jammed with couples making their way from the office of the registration clerk to the office of the judge who would perform a civil ceremony.

Impotence in the Arab World

The incomparable Mark Steyn:

Last month mass hysteria apparently swept the [Sudanese] capital city, Khartoum, after reports that foreigners were shaking hands with Sudanese men and causing their penises to disappear....

"Another victim, who refused to give his name, said that while he was at the market, a man approached him, gave him a comb, and asked him to comb his hair. When he did so, within seconds, he said, he felt a strange sensation and discovered that he had lost his penis."

Tales of the vanishing penises ran rampant round the city, spread by cell phones and text messages...

...it's useful to be reminded that the International Jewish Conspiracy is comparatively one of the less loopy conspiracies in the Islamic world. That said, they'll probably figure out a way to pin the disappearing penises on some or other agent of Zionism. After all, according to reports in Middle East newspapers, Israel laces Arab chewing gum with secret hormones to make Muslim men hot for Jewish babes who turn out to be Mossad agents....

It is, in that sense, the perfect emblematic tale of Islamic victimhood: The foreigners have made us impotent! It doesn't matter that the foreigners didn't do anything except shake hands. It doesn't matter whether you are, in fact, impotent. You feel impotent, just as -- so we're told -- millions of Muslims from Algerian Islamists to the Bali bombers feel "humiliated" by the Palestinian situation. Whether or not there is a rational basis for their sense of humiliation is irrelevant.

...There's something pathetic about a culture so ignorant even its pathologies have to be imported. But what do you expect? The telling detail of the vanishing penis hysteria is that it was spread by text messaging. You can own a cell phone, yet still believe that foreigners are able with a mere handshake to cause your penis to melt away. [SunTimes]

Hillary Clinton, Chutzpah

Hillary Clinton adduces the Founding Fathers in her defense of second-handedness:

"Our Declaration of Independence calls for a deepened respect for the opinions of mankind, but this administration simply doesn't listen. From our most important allies in Europe to our relations with neighbors in this hemisphere this administration has spanned the range of emotions from dismissive to indifferent," [Sen. Clinton] added. [NYSun]

Airheads and Worse Against the Occupation

From an interesting article by Michelle Goldberg about the impotence of the antiwar movement:

Allan Johnson, a high school English teacher and debate coach from Fairfax, Va., held a sign saying "U.S. Troops Out of Iraq. Bring Them Home Now!" at Saturday's "End the Occupation" rally in Washington. In fact, though, Johnson isn't sure he wants to bring the troops home now, or to end the American occupation of Iraq. At least, not yet.

"We've made a giant mess," said Johnson, a handsome man who wore his long snowy hair in a ponytail and had a sparkling stud in one ear. "I would hate for the Bush administration to halfway fix things and then leave, and then blame the Iraqis if things go wrong. Once you go to somebody's house and break all the windows, don't you owe them new windows?"

Why, then, was he marching at an End the Occupation rally? "I don't agree with all the people here, believe you me," he said. But his own sign? He glanced at it, startled, and explained that someone had handed it to him. "I didn't even look at it," he said. "I was just waving it."

...According to an ANSWER pamphlet, "Counter-revolution & Resistance in Iraq," "The anti-war movement here and around the world must give its unconditional support to the Iraqi anti-colonial resistance." [Salon, Hat Tip: Taranto]

Voice of Capitalism

Capitalism news delivered every Monday to your email inbox.

Subscribed. Check your email box for confirmation.

Pin It on Pinterest